Skip to content
DE

Celtic sea salt: minerals, health claims and risks

Clinical review pending

Celtic sea salt compared: minerals, sodium and whether trace minerals offer any health benefit.

Does Celtic sea salt offer a health benefit on top of its flavor? Its moist texture and traditional production make it an appealing finishing salt. As an extra source of minerals, though, it is often overrated. For health, what matters most is how much sodium the diet supplies overall and whether iodine intake is adequate. How much magnesium this salt contributes remains unclear, because the reported amounts contradict each other.

What sets Celtic sea salt apart

Celtic sea salt is a gray, hand-harvested sea salt from the salt pans on the Breton coast of France. It is minimally processed, so small amounts of other minerals from seawater are retained, including magnesium, potassium and calcium. Its gray-blue color and residual moisture are attributed to clay particles from the harvesting ponds. The salt described here has no added iodine.

Even at 5–10 g of salt per day, the extra mineral contribution is considered negligible. This amount is not an intake recommendation. For magnesium, no final judgment can be made yet, because the reported amounts contradict each other.

Sel gris has been harvested for centuries in the salt marshes of Guérande and along the neighboring Breton coast. In the United States, a new wellness trend has made the salt popular as a functional food. In functional medicine circles it is even presented as a “trace mineral delivery system.”

Celtic sea salt is often confused with pink Himalayan salt, fleur de sel or rock salt from Utah. These products differ in origin and production, however. Himalayan salt is a rock salt with different mineral inclusions. Fleur de sel is skimmed as a thin layer of salt from the surface of the same French salt marshes. The rock salt mined in Utah is also a different type of salt.

How many minerals the salt provides

Magnesium, potassium and calcium do different jobs in the body, and each has its own reference values for intake. With salt, it therefore pays to look at quantities: how much of a mineral does a pinch actually supply, and what share of the whole diet does that represent?

Per gram of salt Celtic sea salt Pink Himalayan salt Iodized table salt
Sodium About 375–385 mg (95–98 percent sodium chloride by weight) 395 mg (average of 31 pink salts) 428 mg (1 sample)
Magnesium 1–5 mg (0.1–0.5 percent by weight) 2.7 mg 0.08 mg
Potassium Traces, not quantified 2.4 mg 0.15 mg
Calcium Traces, not quantified 2.7 mg 0.39 mg
Iodine Not added Usually not iodized 45 µg (US labeling)

Sources for the table: study of unrefined sea and rock salts, analysis of pink salt available in Australia and NIH: Iodine: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals.

The numbers do not all add up. At 1–5 mg of magnesium per gram of salt, 5–10 g of salt works out to 5–50 mg of magnesium. That does not match the amount also given elsewhere, “a few milligrams at most.” The figure of 428 mg of sodium per gram of table salt also needs explaining, since pure sodium chloride contains about 393 mg of sodium per gram by calculation. The table therefore does not yet allow a reliable comparison of all the amounts. The iodine figure explicitly refers to US labeling and cannot be applied to every iodized salt.

Sodium chloride

Sodium chloride acts the same way in the body whether it comes from Celtic sea salt or ordinary table salt. For cardiovascular risk, what counts is total daily sodium intake. The brand of salt does not change that.

Trace magnesium

Celtic sea salt contains small amounts of magnesium. The reference value given for magnesium intake is roughly 300–400 mg per day. How much of that 5–10 g of salt a day would supply cannot be determined reliably from the contradictory figures. The description “a few milligrams at most” would suggest a nutritionally negligible contribution, but it does not agree with the values in the table.

The amounts come from the analysis of salt composition. Until the contradiction is resolved, the assessment of the magnesium contribution also remains open. Calling the amount of salt “typical for cooking” does not turn it into a health-recommended amount.

Trace potassium

Potassium is often highlighted in the marketing of specialty salts. Meaningful effects on blood pressure, however, require amounts that are orders of magnitude larger than the traces in ordinary servings of salt. A systematic review and a dose-response meta-analysis support a benefit of higher potassium intake for blood pressure and cardiovascular health. No corresponding benefit can be inferred for the small amounts of potassium in sea salt.

No added iodine

Iodization means deliberately enriching table salt with iodine to improve intake across the population. Iodized salt is one of the most important dietary sources of iodine worldwide. Its importance for adequate intake is described in papers on iodine deficiency, on the re-emerging supply problem and on global recommendations and dietary trends.

If iodized salt has been your main source so far, switching to non-iodized salt can raise the risk of iodine deficiency. This applies especially when the diet contains no other reliable sources of iodine.

How sodium and the other minerals act in the body

The fact that a salt contains a mineral says little about its effect at the amounts people normally use. For that, the amount taken in has to be large enough.

The effect of sodium on blood pressure is one of the best-studied dose-response relationships in nutrition science. Randomized trials consistently show that reducing sodium intake lowers blood pressure. How far it drops depends, among other things, on how much intake is reduced. What matters is total daily sodium intake, regardless of the brand of salt.

For potassium, prospective observational data show an association between sodium and potassium excretion in 24-hour urine and cardiovascular risk. These data alone, however, do not show that adequate potassium intake protects the heart independently of other factors.

Fruit, vegetables, dairy products and legumes supply meaningful amounts of potassium. The traces in sea salt add little to that. Potassium has been called the “Cinderella electrolyte”, roughly meaning an underappreciated electrolyte, because many adults consistently get too little of it from food. Switching salt brands does not close this gap.

The body needs iodine to make thyroid hormones. A deficiency is linked to thyroid dysfunction and adverse pregnancy outcomes, including impaired neurological development. That is why public salt iodization programs exist. An epidemiological study from China is cited as evidence of the long-term success of universal iodization.

Too much iodine can also do harm: a high iodine intake can impair thyroid function. The goal is adequate intake without taking in excessive amounts of iodine.

How solid are the claims about Celtic sea salt?

Marketing for Celtic sea salt usually focuses on its magnesium, potassium and calcium content, on health advantages over table salt and on electrolyte and fluid balance. Minimal processing is also presented as a plus. For each claim, the question is whether it describes a property of the salt or whether a health benefit has been shown.

Dietary contribution of magnesium, potassium and calcium: rated as anecdotal

Composition analyses confirm small proportions of these minerals by weight. Whether they contribute meaningfully to intake depends on how much is eaten. At 5–10 g of salt per day, the contributions to magnesium and potassium intake are estimated to fall far below the respective reference values. For magnesium, though, this assessment remains unresolved because of the contradictory figures.

So the statement that the salt contains minerals can be factually correct and still give an exaggerated impression of its benefit. The rating “anecdotal” here refers to the claimed dietary contribution, not to the analytical detection of the minerals.

Healthier than table salt: rated as anecdotal

Sodium intake is associated with cardiovascular risk. A described dose-response relationship concerns the amount of sodium, but it does not allow a direct comparison of specialty salts with iodized table salt. A health advantage at the same sodium dose has therefore not been shown for cardiovascular endpoints, meaning outcomes related to heart and blood vessel health. Whether controlled head-to-head comparison studies exist remains unclear.

Unrefined salt does contain no added anti-caking agents. For most people, this difference is considered to have little clinical significance; no established health benefit can be derived from it here.

Electrolyte balance and hydration: limited evidence

Sodium is needed for fluid balance. It fulfills this function no matter which type of salt it comes from. The small amounts of other minerals in typical cooking portions are not credited with any meaningful extra benefit as an electrolyte replacement.

For athletic exertion, purpose-formulated electrolyte products with balanced ratios of sodium, potassium and magnesium are an option. The claim that their evidence is across the board much stronger than that for Celtic sea salt, however, comes without specific support. Nor is it shown here which particular mineral ratios offer an advantage.

Less processed and free of additives: limited evidence

Composition studies confirm that minimal processing preserves mineral inclusions and moisture. A health benefit on clinical endpoints does not automatically follow. The salt described here also has no added iodine. With regular use, iodine intake therefore has to be secured from other sources.

Safety, iodine and situations that call for caution

For most healthy adults, moderate use of Celtic sea salt in cooking is generally considered unproblematic. “Typical for cooking,” however, does not describe a defined safe dose. In particular, the 5–10 g of salt per day mentioned earlier must not be assumed to be harmless across the board.

When switching salt types, the main things to watch are iodine intake and any limits on sodium intake. If iodized salt drops out, iodine intake can get worse. Iodine deficiency is again being described as a problem as eating habits change. With heart failure, chronic kidney disease from stage 3 onward, and high blood pressure managed with a medically supervised low-sodium diet, limiting sodium intake may be necessary. The brand of salt does not change these limits; specific sodium targets have to be set individually by a doctor.

Direct drug interactions are described as rare for salt itself. Sodium intake can, however, affect how well blood pressure medications from various drug classes work. Salt products with added potassium bring further risks: blends with potassium chloride marketed as “low sodium” can promote hyperkalemia when combined with ACE inhibitors, angiotensin receptor blockers (ARBs) or aldosterone antagonists. Hyperkalemia means too high a level of potassium in the blood.

In chronic kidney disease in particular, the body’s ability to excrete potassium through the kidneys can be limited. That is why special caution is needed with potassium-enriched salt products. Whether they must be avoided or can be used in an individual case belongs in personal, medically guided dietary planning. A review of nutritional management in chronic kidney disease is cited on this point. Ordinary Celtic sea salt should be distinguished from salt substitutes deliberately enriched with potassium.

With regular use of Celtic sea salt, iodine intake is the main concern. The consequences of a deficiency can be especially far-reaching during pregnancy. Possible impairments of neurological development cannot, however, be described as irreversible across the board. That depends on the severity and timing of the deficiency and on the type of developmental impairment.

A recent change of salt source can also matter for lab tests. It could affect the iodine concentration in urine and how a TSH value is interpreted; how meaningful this link is in an individual case remains a clinical question. When thyroid values are measured, such a switch therefore belongs among the relevant dietary details. Sodium and potassium values from a single urine sample can likewise be influenced by recent dietary changes.

A medical assessment is especially worthwhile in the following situations:

  • In pregnancy, adequate iodine intake is essential. If iodized salt is dropped and no iodine-containing prenatal supplement is taken, intake deserves particular attention. Not taking a supplement does not by itself prove a deficiency; the rest of the iodine intake has to be taken into account. No blanket recommendation to supplement follows from this.
  • With heart failure or chronic kidney disease with sodium or potassium restriction, the agreed limits apply regardless of the salt brand. Potassium-enriched salt blends can pose an added risk in chronic kidney disease.
  • With high blood pressure and a low-sodium diet, total sodium intake is still what counts. Changes in salt use can be discussed as part of ongoing treatment.
  • With a thyroid condition, or a risk of one, it is worth checking whether iodine intake is adequate if Celtic sea salt becomes the main source of salt.
  • Before thyroid values or urine electrolytes are measured, a recent change of salt source is relevant information for the doctor’s interpretation.

Which measurements can capture a salt switch

How you feel is not a reliable way to tell whether a salt switch has changed anything. For healthy adults, though, this does not create a general need for lab tests. Whether measurements make sense depends on your health situation and the specific question.

Comparable measurements on day 0 and day N can in principle be used to capture changes. To assess salt intake, sodium and potassium in urine are described as more informative than the corresponding values in serum. The measurements answer different questions:

  • Sodium, potassium and magnesium in serum are tightly regulated by the body. A routine electrolyte panel can provide baseline values before a dietary change, but that alone does not create a need for testing.
  • Sodium and potassium in 24-hour urine collected under clinical conditions are considered especially informative for capturing intake, where the test is available. A study on cardiovascular risk links these measures directly to a dose-response relationship. It shows an association, not automatic proof of a causal effect in an individual.
  • Blood pressure can reflect changes in total sodium intake. A period of 4–8 weeks is given for a repeat measurement after a major change, to capture a physiological shift. Whether this interval fits the specific situation has to be judged in the context of treatment.
  • TSH, possibly supplemented by urinary iodine, may be worth considering when iodized salt is replaced as the main source of salt. The switch has to be taken into account when interpreting results; on its own it does not justify a test.

A switch of salt brand alone does not justify general lab testing. Changed values do not automatically prove a causal effect, either. Which tests can answer a specific question has to be settled clinically.

If values change in the way you would expect from lower sodium intake or adequate potassium intake, that may fit an effect of the changed diet. The salt brand itself is very likely not the deciding factor. For blood pressure, looking at the diet as a whole is therefore more useful than comparing individual salt brands.

Where Celtic sea salt makes sense

Celtic sea salt has its place in the kitchen when flavor, texture and culinary tradition are what tip the balance. Its mineral inclusions are credited with a distinctive flavor profile that many people prefer for finishing dishes.

It can also be a reasonable choice for people whose adequate iodine intake from other sources is documented. Regularly eaten seafood, dairy products or an iodine-containing dietary supplement can contribute to that.

A meaningful benefit as a mineral supplement, as a way to lower blood pressure or as a healthier alternative to table salt, on the other hand, has not been shown. The small extra amounts of minerals cannot carry such expectations; the exact magnesium contribution remains unresolved. For a DASH diet or a Mediterranean diet, there are studies on blood pressure reduction, including an overview of salt restriction, DASH and the Mediterranean diet. The further claim of much stronger evidence on cardiovascular endpoints cannot yet be supported by this alone.

What can influence the advertised health goals

Depending on the concern, different approaches may help with the health goals that Celtic sea salt is marketed for. The mineral amounts in ordinary servings of salt do not offer a convincing basis for them.

For lowering blood pressure, the overall dietary pattern is what matters. A meta-analysis of randomized trials shows clinically meaningful blood pressure reductions with a DASH diet. The Mediterranean diet is also discussed in this context. The meta-analysis cited here, however, explicitly studies DASH; its results cannot simply be carried over to the Mediterranean diet.

For iodine and potassium intake, the combination of iodized table salt and potassium-rich foods is better supported by evidence than relying on trace minerals in specialty salts. Fruit, vegetables, dairy products and legumes supply potassium. Global recommendations on iodine intake continue to support iodized salt as the central means of securing adequate intake. That does not mean eating more salt overall.

For endurance sports and heavy sweat losses, purpose-formulated electrolyte products can supply meaningful amounts of electrolytes. Products with balanced ratios of sodium, potassium and magnesium are mentioned. There is no specific evidence here, however, for a blanket recommendation of particular ratios. Needs and composition have to match the specific exertion.

What baseline matters before making a change

Switching salt brands counts among the cheaper dietary changes. Its effects are likely to be small, though. Claims about blood pressure, urinary sodium or TSH can in principle be tested with specific measurements. A vague promise of feeling better is harder to check. For measurable changes, what matters most is what changes in the diet as a whole.

Sometimes a health concern lies behind the interest in salt: fatigue that could point to an undiagnosed thyroid condition, persistently high blood pressure, or symptoms consistent with chronic kidney disease. In these cases, a clinical workup is appropriate. Switching brands does not explain what is causing the symptoms.

Bottom line on Celtic sea salt

Flavor, texture and culinary tradition can justify the price of Celtic sea salt for enthusiasts. The support for a health advantage over table salt is rated as merely anecdotal. The literature on salt intake and cardiovascular risk cited here concerns total intake and does not directly answer the comparison between salt types.

A simple brand switch is unlikely to have much effect on blood pressure, urinary sodium and potassium, or TSH. If the diet as a whole or iodine intake changes substantially, on the other hand, effects are possible. Whether tests are needed depends on the individual situation. When replacing iodized salt, the main question is how iodine intake will continue to be secured.

Frequently asked questions

Is Celtic sea salt healthier than regular salt?

No meaningful health advantage is apparent. Celtic sea salt is about 95–98% sodium chloride, which makes it similar to ordinary table salt. Compared with intake from food, the contribution of the extra minerals is considered nutritionally negligible. For magnesium, however, the contradictory figures still need to be resolved.

One difference from iodized table salt is that unprocessed Celtic sea salt has no added iodine. When you use it, iodine intake from other sources has to be taken into account. The missing iodine is not a health advantage in itself.

Does Celtic sea salt contain minerals the body needs?

Yes. It contains small amounts of magnesium, potassium, calcium and other trace elements. Their contribution to intake is considered small compared with the rest of the diet. How much magnesium the salt actually contributes can only be assessed more precisely once the contradictory figures have been resolved.

Does Celtic sea salt actually do anything?

As a seasoning salt, it does its job. A meaningful benefit as a mineral supplement or for lowering blood pressure, on the other hand, has not been shown. The small extra amounts of minerals and a sodium chloride composition that is largely comparable to table salt give no reason to expect such a benefit. The exact magnesium contribution remains open.

Is Celtic sea salt healthy?

What matters is total daily sodium intake and the rest of the diet, such as a DASH or Mediterranean eating pattern. At normal amounts of use, the salt brand itself is credited with only a small independent influence. The meta-analysis on salt intake and cardiovascular disease cited here also examines salt intake as a whole.

Is Celtic sea salt safe?

For healthy adults, moderate use in cooking is generally considered unproblematic. If you mainly use non-iodized specialty salts, adequate iodine intake is important. A review of iodine deficiency describes why. This does not confirm that the 5–10 g of salt per day mentioned elsewhere is harmless across the board.

Does Celtic sea salt have side effects?

Only a few specific side effects are mentioned for Celtic sea salt. If it is your main salt, iodine intake can become inadequate when other iodine sources are missing. The supply problem is covered in a review of the re-emerging problem of iodine deficiency. In addition, the usual risks of too much sodium chloride apply to Celtic sea salt as well.

Who should not eat or drink Celtic sea salt?

With heart failure or chronic kidney disease with sodium or potassium restriction, and with high blood pressure on a low-sodium diet, the individually agreed limits apply. In pregnancy, iodine intake deserves particular attention if no prenatal iodine supplement is taken. Not taking such a supplement does not by itself prove inadequate intake, though, and it does not justify avoiding Celtic sea salt across the board. What matters is total iodine intake and any necessary restriction of sodium or, where relevant, potassium.

Specialty salt products with a higher potassium content can be especially problematic in advanced chronic kidney disease; a review of nutritional management in kidney disease is cited on this point. Such deliberately potassium-enriched salt substitutes should be distinguished from ordinary Celtic sea salt.

What tests are needed before trying Celtic sea salt?

Most healthy adults do not need any special tests before trying a different salt for cooking. If iodized salt drops out as the main source of salt and other reliable iodine sources are missing, talking to a doctor about intake can be worthwhile. That conversation can also settle whether TSH and urinary iodine should be measured. Urinary iodine is not a blood test.

If you are on a low-sodium diet plan because of heart failure, chronic kidney disease or high blood pressure, the monitoring schedule already agreed with your doctor still applies.

Sources

  • Karavoltsos S, Sakellari A, Bakeas E, Bekiaris G, Plavšić M, Proestos C, Zinelis S, Koukoulakis K, Diakos I, Dassenakis M, Kalogeropoulos N (2020). Trace elements, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, mineral composition, and FT-IR characterization of unrefined sea and rock salts: environmental interactions. Environmental science and pollution research international, 27(10), 10857-10868. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11356-020-07670-2
  • Strazzullo P, D’Elia L, Kandala NB, Cappuccio FP (2009). Salt intake, stroke, and cardiovascular disease: meta-analysis of prospective studies. BMJ (Clinical research ed.), 339, b4567. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.b4567
  • Filippini T, Naska A, Kasdagli MI, Torres D, Lopes C, Carvalho C, Moreira P, Malavolti M, Orsini N, Whelton PK, Vinceti M (2020). Potassium Intake and Blood Pressure: A Dose-Response Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Journal of the American Heart Association, 9(12), e015719. https://doi.org/10.1161/JAHA.119.015719
  • Aburto NJ, Hanson S, Gutierrez H, Hooper L, Elliott P, Cappuccio FP (2013). Effect of increased potassium intake on cardiovascular risk factors and disease: systematic review and meta-analyses. BMJ (Clinical research ed.), 346, f1378. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.f1378
  • Zimmermann MB (2009). Iodine deficiency. Endocrine reviews, 30(4), 376-408. https://doi.org/10.1210/er.2009-0011
  • Bath SC (2024). Thyroid function and iodine intake: global recommendations and relevant dietary trends. Nature reviews. Endocrinology, 20(8), 474-486. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41574-024-00983-z
  • Hatch-McChesney A, Lieberman HR (2022). Iodine and Iodine Deficiency: A Comprehensive Review of a Re-Emerging Issue. Nutrients, 14(17). https://doi.org/10.3390/nu14173474
  • Huang L, Trieu K, Yoshimura S, Neal B, Woodward M, Campbell NRC, Li Q, Lackland DT, Leung AA, Anderson CAM, MacGregor GA, He FJ (2020). Effect of dose and duration of reduction in dietary sodium on blood pressure levels: systematic review and meta-analysis of randomised trials. BMJ (Clinical research ed.), 368, m315. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.m315
  • Filippini T, Malavolti M, Whelton PK, Naska A, Orsini N, Vinceti M (2021). Blood Pressure Effects of Sodium Reduction: Dose-Response Meta-Analysis of Experimental Studies. Circulation, 143(16), 1542-1567. https://doi.org/10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.120.050371
  • Ma Y, He FJ, Sun Q, Yuan C, Kieneker LM, Curhan GC, MacGregor GA, Bakker SJL, Campbell NRC, Wang M, Rimm EB, Manson JE, Willett WC, Hofman A, Gansevoort RT, Cook NR, Hu FB (2022). 24-Hour Urinary Sodium and Potassium Excretion and Cardiovascular Risk. The New England journal of medicine, 386(3), 252-263. https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2109794
  • O’Donnell M, Yusuf S, Vogt L, Mente A, Messerli FH (2023). Potassium intake: the Cinderella electrolyte. European heart journal, 44(47), 4925-4934. https://doi.org/10.1093/eurheartj/ehad628
  • Zimmermann MB, Boelaert K (2015). Iodine deficiency and thyroid disorders. The lancet. Diabetes & endocrinology, 3(4), 286-95. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2213-8587(14)70225-6
  • Fayet-Moore F, Wibisono C, Carr P, Duve E, Petocz P, Lancaster G, McMillan J, Marshall S, Blumfield M (2020). An Analysis of the Mineral Composition of Pink Salt Available in Australia. Foods (Basel, Switzerland), 9(10), 1490. https://doi.org/10.3390/foods9101490 PubMed
  • National Institutes of Health Office of Dietary Supplements (n.d.). Iodine: Fact Sheet for Health Professionals. https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Iodine-HealthProfessional/
  • Li Y, Teng D, Ba J, Chen B, Du J, He L, Lai X, Teng X, Shi X, Li Y, Chi H, Liao E, Liu C, Liu L, Qin G, Qin Y, Quan H, Shi B, Sun H, … Teng W (2020). Efficacy and Safety of Long-Term Universal Salt Iodization on Thyroid Disorders: Epidemiological Evidence from 31 Provinces of Mainland China. Thyroid : official journal of the American Thyroid Association, 30(4), 568-579. https://doi.org/10.1089/thy.2019.0067
  • Farebrother J, Zimmermann MB, Andersson M (2019). Excess iodine intake: sources, assessment, and effects on thyroid function. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1446(1), 44-65. https://doi.org/10.1111/nyas.14041
  • Zhu Y, Zhang J, Li Z, Liu Y, Fan X, Zhang Y, Zhang Y (2018). Association of sodium intake and major cardiovascular outcomes: a dose-response meta-analysis of prospective cohort studies. BMC cardiovascular disorders, 18(1), 192. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12872-018-0927-9
  • Kim SM, Jung JY (2020). Nutritional management in patients with chronic kidney disease. The Korean journal of internal medicine, 35(6), 1279-1290. https://doi.org/10.3904/kjim.2020.408
  • Filippou C, Tatakis F, Polyzos D, Manta E, Thomopoulos C, Nihoyannopoulos P, Tousoulis D, Tsioufis K (2022). Overview of salt restriction in the Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) and the Mediterranean diet for blood pressure reduction. Reviews in cardiovascular medicine, 23(1), 36. https://doi.org/10.31083/j.rcm2301036
  • Filippou CD, Tsioufis CP, Thomopoulos CG, Mihas CC, Dimitriadis KS, Sotiropoulou LI, Chrysochoou CA, Nihoyannopoulos PI, Tousoulis DM (2020). Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) Diet and Blood Pressure Reduction in Adults with and without Hypertension: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. Advances in nutrition (Bethesda, Md.), 11(5), 1150-1160. https://doi.org/10.1093/advances/nmaa041